- 'Comprehensive, representative, good guidance and advice', Dr Andrew Dawson, Chester College
- 'The selection of articles is exceptionally good for an introductory course in the subject. The questions are also useful for discussion in class and writing projects', Dr Victoria S Harrison, Birkbeck College
Philosophy of Religion: A Guide and Anthology provides a comprehensive, authoritative, and accessible overview of the philosophy of religion. Under the careful editorship of Brian Davies, the book contains a selection of the best classical and contemporary writings on the philosophy of religion together with substantial commentary, introductory material, discussion questions, and detailed guides to further reading. The editorial material sets the extracts in context and guides the reader through them. Taken as a whole, the book offers the ideal, self-contained introduction to the questions which have most preoccupied Western philosophers when thinking about religion. The selection is both very comprehensive and very generous. 65 sizeable extracts map out the full range of topics most commonly encountered in courses on the philosophy of religion. Part I looks at the relation between philosophy and religious belief; Parts II-IV consider the existence and nature of God; Part V addresses the 'problem of evil'; and Parts VI and VII are devoted to the relationship between morality and religion and to the question of life after death.
Preface
General Introduction
Advice on Reading
PART I. PHILOSOPHY AND RELIGIOUS BELIEF
Introduction
1. Faith and Reason in Harmony, Thomas Aquinas
2. The Ethics of Belief, W.K. Clifford
3. The Presumption of Atheism, Antony Flew
4. Religious Belief as 'Properly Basic', Alvin Plantinga
5. Evidence and Religious Belief, Norman Kretzmann
6. Grammar and Religious Belief, D.Z. Phillips
7. The Groundlessness of Religious Belief, Norman Malcolm
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Further Reading
PART II. THE PROBLEM OF GOD-TALK
Introduction
8. How Believers Find God-Talk Puzzling, Augustine of Hippo
9. God-Talk is Evidently Nonsense, A.J. Ayer
10. God-Talk is Not Evidently Nonsense, Richard Swinburne
11. 'Death by a Thousand Qualifications', Antony Flew
12. One Way of Understanding God-Talk, Thomas Aquinas
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Reading
PART III. ARGUMENTS FOR GOD'S EXISTENCE
Introduction
Advice on Reading
Cosmological Arguments
Introduction
13. A Concise Cosmological Argument from the Eleventh Century, Anselm of Canterbury
14. A Thirteenth Century Cosmological Argument, Thomas Aquinas
15. A Fourteenth-Century Cosmological Argument, John Duns Scotus
16. A Seventeenth-Century Cosmological Argument, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz
17. A Modern Cosmological Argument, Herbert McCabe
18. Objections to Cosmological Arguments, Paul Edwards
19. More Objections to Cosmological Arguments, J.L. Mackie
20. Why is a Cause Always Necessary?, David Hume
21. 'Whatever Has a Beginning of Existence Must Have a Cause', G.E.M. Anscombe
22. Can there be an Endless Regress of Causes?, James A. Sadowsky
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Further Reading
23. Design ArgumentsIntroduction, Thomas Aquinas
Introduction
29. Anselm Argues That God Cannot Be Thought Not To Exist, Anselm of Canterbury
30. Gaunilo Argues that Anselm is Wrong, Gaunilo of Marmoutiers
31. Anselm Replies to Gaunilo, Anselm of Canterbury
32. Descartes Defends An Ontological Argument, Rene Descartes
33. Descartes Replies to Critics, Pierre Gassendi, Johannes Caterus, Rene Descartes
34. A Classic Repudiation of Ontological Arguments, Immanuel Kant
35. A Contemporary Defence of Ontological Arguments, Alvin Plantinga
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Reading
God and Human Experience
Introduction
36. Why 'Knowing God by Experience' is a Notion Open to Question, C.B. Martin
37. Can We Know God by Experience?, Peter Donovan
38. Why Should There Not Be Experience of God?, William P. Alston
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Reading
PART IV. WHAT IS GOD?
Introduction
Advice on Further Reading
Omnipotent
Introduction
39. A Modern Discussion of Divine Omnipotence, Thomas V. Morris
40. Why Think of God as Omnipotent?, Thomas Aquinas
41. Miracles and Laws of Nature, Richard Swinburne
42. Why We Should Disbelieve in Miracles, David Hume
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Reading
Knowing
Introduction
43. Why Ascribe Knowledge to God?, Thomas Aquinas
44. Omniscience and Human Freedom: a Classic Discussion, Boethius
45. Problems for the Notion of Divine Omniscience, Nelson Pike
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Further Reading
Eternal
Introduction
46. Why Call God 'Eternal'?, Thomas Aquinas
47. God is 'Everlasting', not 'Eternal', Nicholas Wolterstorff
48. A Modern Defence of Divine Eternity, Eleonore Stump and Norman Kretzmann
49. A Different Modern Defence of Divine Eternity. Paul Helm
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Reading
Simple
Introduction
50. A Classic Defence of Divine Simplicity, Thomas Aquinas
51. Problems with Divine Simplicity, Thomas V. Morris
52. A Modern Defence of Divine Simplicity, Brian Davies
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Further Reading
Part V. THE PROBLEM OF EVIL
Introduction
53. Evil Shows that there is no God, J.L. Mackie
54. What is Evil?, Augustine of Hippo
55. Evil Does Not Show That There Is No God, Richard Swinburne
56. God, Evil, and Divine Responsibility, Herbert McCabe
57. God and Human Freedom, Thomas Aquinas
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Reading
Part VI. MORALITY AND RELIGION
Introduction
58. God as a 'Postulate' of Sound Moral Thinking, Immanuel Kant
59. Why Morality Implies the Existence of God, H.P. Owen
60. Moral Thinking as Awareness of God, Illtyd Trethowan
61. Morality does not Imply the Existence of God, Kai Nielsen
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Further Reading
Part VII. PEOPLE AND LIFE AFTER DEATH
Introduction
62. Philosophy and Life After Death: The Questions and the Options, Stephen T. Davis
63. Life After Death: An Ancient Greek View, Plato
64. Belief in Life After Death Comes from Emotion, not Reason, Bertrand Russell
65. What Must be True of Me If I Survive My Death?, Peter Geach
Questions for Discussion
Advice on Further Reading
Index
Brian Davies
`A well-chosen selction of readings which include precisely the main topics essential for a constructive course in philosophy of religion. A well-balanced selection.'
Professor A C Thiselton, University of Nottingham